

Hosted By:
Don Nicholas, Kim Mateus,
and Peter Schaible
Peter A. Schaible is Editor-at-Large for the Mequoda Group. Prior to its merger with the Mequoda Library, he was director of the Subscription Website Publishers Association and executive editor of www.SWEPA.com, the association's website.
Schaible has extensive experience in marketing communications, including stints as an editor of newsletters for the National Exchange Carrier Association, AT&T and IBM Corporation. For more than 20 years he has been president of SunDance New Media, a marketing communications consulting firm. Previously he was director of communications for the United States Golf Association
Reports by Peter A. Schaible
InternationalLiving.com Travel Website Design ReviewToday, most would-be travelers start their journeys online by researching destinations, carrier schedules, accommodations and free web mapping services.
In order to compete with travel agencies and agents, travel information publishers, who traditionally published books, magazines and newsletters, have migrated to the Internet and become online publishers. Some have created retail websites whose primary objective is to sell traditional hard-copy books. Others are focused on publishing travel reviews on their sites, and derive revenue from advertising and affiliate links.
Still others, such as Expedia, Travelocity, Orbitz and Priceline, are Internet travel agencies that place a high value on creating comparisons of prices and schedules. We chose not to review them as part of the top ten because they are retail websites, not media websites.
We make this distinction: The primary goal of a media website is to inform; the primary goal of a retail website is to sell. Similarly, if we were reviewing literature websites, we would not include Amazon.com, which is a retail website whose primary goal is to sell books, not review them.
We did an in-depth examination of 10 most popular travel information websites and evaluated them against 14 criteriaour famous Mequoda website design guidelines. Of the 10 websites, none was perfect, but most were very good and two or three were excellent.
International Living came in as #3, and we'll tell you why.
The Accounts Payable Network describes itself as the most comprehensive, specialized resource available for accounts payable professionals by providingin one convenient, online locationcurrent solutions for AP strategy, technology, people and processes. That's a big promise, especially considering that the membership website was launched less than three years ago (at the time of this writing) by Financial Operations Networks LLC and its founder, Phil Binkow. But The Accounts Payable Network doesn't disappoint; it overwhelms the AP professional with valuable tools and content. Using the Mequoda Website Scorecard, The Accounts Payable Network does an exemplary job of implementing effective design practices. They are a prime example of a successful Mequoda Membership Website.
This review is part of a handbook titled Membership Website Publishing.
TheBookStandard.com describes itself as "the all-inclusive online destination for publishers, retailers, librarians, agents, authors, distributors, studio executives, screenwriters, publicists, book groups and more!" It's an accurate description. VNU Business Media, publisher of The Hollywood Reporter, Billboard, Computing, and other trade titles, launched TheBookStandard.com, its first solely online publication, in January of 2005. It brings together in one online membership website every aspect of the book publishing industry: Nielsen BookScan-powered data, charts, and analysis; news and investigative reporting; industry resources, tools, and commentaryplus reviews powered by Kirkus. TheBookStandard.com succeeds on many levels as measured by the Mequoda Website Scorecard. When measured against the 14 Mequoda best practices, TheBookStandard.com scores a solid "B." Learn what makes this website work and where it could use some adjustments.
This review is part of a handbook titled Membership Website Publishing.
Credit Today is a print newsletter that describes itself as "the premier publication for trade credit professionals." For US $279 annually, subscribers receive 12 issues of Credit Today, and get full access to CreditToday.net, its companion website. The CreditToday.net mission statement is precise: "To give you the tools and insights that will empower you to excel in credit, customer service and business, while providing a forum for the best thinking in the field." Using the Mequoda Website Scorecard, CreditToday.net earns an A and, except for one glaring omission and a single graphic design inconsistency, is a good example of a well engineered B-to-B website. Read this Membership Website Review to get a better understanding of what constitutes effective Membership Website design.
This review is part of a handbook titled Membership Website Publishing.
Providing news and information on how to comply with Federal laws and international banking regulations is the niche addressed by this membership website. Moneylaundering.com Premium is produced by the editors of Moneylaundering Alert, a print newsletter providing information on money laundering in the US and around the world. Moneylaundering.com Premium calls itself the world's leading authority on money laundering news, guidance and analysis, but does its website meet basic standards of website usability and design? This Membership Website Review outlines where Moneylaundering.com does well and where it could use some improvements.
This review is part of a handbook titled Membership Website Publishing.
Mequoda uses the term "archetype" to help understand and categorize kinds of sites. An archetype is a pattern or design upon which all other similar things are patterned. The Mequoda Research Team has analyzed more than 2,000 media websites and concluded there are seven primary archetypes. Each of these seven archetypes has many sub archetypes that represent significant variations in information architecture on the primary theme.
Another common media platform to better understand the concept of a media archetype is television. Television is a media platform that was born in the 1940s. Early television shows were based on media archetypes borrowed from stage, film and radio.
Today, TV producers draw on a rich array of television archetypes that include situation comedies, reality shows, dramas and news magazines. Each archetype can be represented best by an actual show or a collection of shows that are best practice examples for the format, and the same can be done for websites.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
A membership website is a user driven, content-based website satellite that generates the majority of its revenues from user access fees.
B2B publishers often convert loose-leaf information services and their monthly updates into membership websites for ease of updating and easy user access. B2C publishers often convert their back issues into a special-interest library categorized by topic.
Membership websites are used as reference tools by users who seek a trustworthy answer to a specific questionoften as part of an immediate decision-making process. Weve profiled two Mequoda best practice websites, the B2C site, Consumer Reports and the B2B site, The Accounts Payable Network in this chapter.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
Every Retail Media Website has two business goals. First, the website must allow users to buy products. Second, the website must begin a user relationship with both buyers and non-buyers that will lead to future sales.
There are two information architecture strategies that can be used to balance these two goals. Both strategies require two things: a product to sell and free information to give away, usually in the form of periodic email communications (aka: a free email newsletter).
The user has three goals in mind when visiting a Retail Website; find a product that meets their immediate need, discern whether the product meets their need at an acceptable price and purchase the product and ensure its successful delivery. In this chapter, we will discuss the three Retail Sub-Archetypes weve identified to date; Retail Catalog Website, Retail Product Website and Retail Subscription Website.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
Classified websites generate revenue by facilitating commercial transactions between buyers and sellers of products or services. There are at least four major variations of the Classified Website Archetype; Classified Retail Websites, Classified Directory Websites, Classified Employment Websites and Classified Service Websites, all of which we will discuss in this chapter.
The user goals when visiting a Classified Website include: find a product or offer that meets their immediate need, discern whether the offer meets their need at an acceptable price, complete the transaction and ensure its successful delivery.
Classified websites generate revenue from listings fees and commissions for facilitating transactions between parties.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
Lead Generation Websites generate revenue by providing sponsors with qualified leads.
Users shop for products and services in an effort to save time and money, while the seller pays for content creation and co-branding value. Plus, the seller pays a transaction fee for each qualified lead.
In this chapter, we profile two very different lead-generation sites: Lending Tree in the B2C financial space and Computerworld, a B2B technology website network that provides leads for technology companies hoping to sell to information systems executives.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
Hybrid Websites come in many variations as they successfully and often unsuccessfully merge functionality from two or more of the other website archetypes and sub archetypes into a single (often confusing) user interface.
Magazine and newspaper companies often build Hub, Retail Subscription and Membership functionality into a single user interface. The lack of a dedicated, open architecture, content rich, search engine optimized Internet Hub sometimes limits their overall website traffic and revenue generation capability.
In this chapter, we profile both B2B Hybrid Websites and B2C Hybrid websites.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
This Mequoda review of successful publishers, best practices, and the seven predominant models for designing media websites is comprehensive but not final.
Just as advances in technology have produced new media and spawned new strategies for disseminating information, we expect to see additional media archetypes evolve.
Whatever the future holds, whatever new business models emerge, the Mequoda Group will continue to help publishers master the Internet.
This handbook draws heavily on the more than 450 research reports contained in the Mequoda Library, a membership website. This chapter of the book lists all the references.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
How do you introduce a topic that is redefining the publishing industry in ways that most of us do not fully comprehend?
For those of us not yet ready to retire, new thinking is required. We must redefine ourselves as media professionals and redefine the way we meet the information needs of our audience. Instead of publishing a single magazine or newsletter, we need to offer users information and entertainment on a variety of platforms using a variety of business models and marketing channels.
The Web is key to this strategy as it represents the 24/7 nexus for all the information and entertainment we have to offer. And whether the users media experience will be virtual or physical, online or offline, the user expects to find current information about the experience on the World Wide Web any time, day or night.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
Mequoda views Internet Hubs as one of the most important website archetypes available to a publisher. Without a well-designed, well-marketed Internet Hub, an online publisher is forced to rely on other websites and other media to drive targeted website traffic.
An Internet Hub is very robust, offering tons of useful information for free. It is designed to maximize online advertising inventory. State-of-the-art Internet Hubs offer users email newsletters, blogs, email alerts and RSS feeds that are all designed to directly and indirectly generate more page views and website revenue.
Internet Hubs generate value from both the users and the sponsors. The user pays with time and information. They spend time viewing web pages, emails and RSS feeds thus creating advertising inventory that can be used to sell the publishers products and/or that can be sold to third party sponsors.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
Brand Websites are used by all manner of non-online product and service organizations to build brand preference for the organizations offline products and services. Brand Websites exist to alert consumers to online and brick and mortar retailers where purchases can occur.
On Brand Websites, users get product or service information and the revenue model is to increase retail spending, similar to other non-direct response advertising.
Brand websites, while not transaction based, are still essential for any company hoping to establish credibility and preference with its customers. A B2B and a B2C brand website are profiled in this section.
This chapter is part of a handbook titled Generating Website Revenue 2007.
For individuals with money to invest, the search for undervalued growth stocks now leads to Asia, spawning a brace of new investment advisory newsletters.
China Investment Report by Business Financial Publishing, LLC may be a worthy publication, but its sales letter landing page makes our reviewer's head hurt.
This site is unattractive, lacks a compelling headline, looks out of date, and sells your email address to its confederates without your explicit consent. It's a poster child for bad online marketing practices.
Learn the three biggest mistakes this landing page makes and easy steps it could take to see immediate improvements.
Understand how even the tiniest of oversights can have the most dramatic impact on the success and conversion rate of your sales letter landing page.
Choosing & Using the Right Information Architecture For Your Media Website Network
Gas stations, supermarkets and bookstores are all retail businesses, yet the specifics of their business model and their physical infrastructure are very different. Building the right infrastructure supports higher revenue, lower operating costs and happier customers.
Online publishing also supports different business models and each business model requires specific infrastructure to optimize the user experience, maximize revenue and keep costs low. Unlike a physical gas station or bookstore operator, the successful online publisher interacts with their customer in a virtual infrastructure. The nexus of this virtual infrastructure is called a website and is defined by its information architecture.
In this report, well consider the ways in which you can design media websites that will best encourage users to interact with your media brand, develop a trusted relationship, and generate website revenue for your organization in the process.
FDAnews is the premier provider of domestic and international regulatory, legislative and business news and information for executives in industries regulated by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
There are numerous "80/20 rules" that business people quote to explain the relationship between effort and results. One 80/20 rule says that 80 percent of your sales are derived from 20 percent of your customers. Another says that 80 percent of your revenue is derived from 20 percent of your products.
In a brand and audience focusing exercise, FDAnews president Cynthia Carter launched FDAnews.com when she recognized, immediately and intuitively, that the FDA information at her new employer's publishing company was a small portionperhaps 20 percent of the entire contentbut accounted for 80 percent of revenues.
That was in 2000. Today, FDAnews has in excess of 75,000 unique names in its marketing file. Each of these is a subscriber to at least one of seven free email newsletters and is worth an average of $65. In the past six years, the publishing company has increased revenues four-fold, aggregating 80 percent of its new business from online marketing.
The Gray Lady has been tweaking its online subscription model incessantly over the past few years. With its latest version, TimesSelect, casual visitors can't get access to the vast online library of past articles without making a $4.95 to $49.95 purchase.
The TimesSelect access challenge landing page is one of the best we have seen. And it's clearly working, generating more than a half million new subscribers in its first 12 months and adding more than $6 million in revenue to the New York Times bottom line since January 2006.
The Internet is a constantly evolving medium. Websites get redesigned, either owing to new graphics, new content, or because the essential architecture is inadequate to serve the site visitors.
If the human factors haven't been properly addressedif visitors can't easily find what they're looking for or can't order your product easilyyou've got insurmountable problems that mandate you to re-engineer your website.
That was not the case with the publishers of the Andrew Harper's Hideaway Report. Their previous landing page design was not totally dysfunctional; but it needed more pizzazz to sell its fine, upscale niche newsletter.
In the time since we first published a review of the AndrewHarperTravel.com landing page some 18 months ago, a number of website design elements have changed for the better. Unfortunately, some other elements have gotten worse. There is still plenty of room for improvement.
When you publish under the aegis of Harvard University, your primary objective is not simply to make money; it's to improve the health and quality of life for the general public. And protecting Harvard's brand is of utmost importance.
An informative interview with Ed Coburn, Publishing Director, Harvard Health Publications, provided valuable insights into a profitable business model whose highest priority isn't profits.
The Mequoda Group estimates that the Agora Financial Network will post top-line revenues for 2006 of $55 million, with $41 million being generated online. This makes each of its 500,000 domestic subscribers worth about $82.
Like all Mequoda Marketing Systems, the Agora Financial Network offers both the Daily Reckoning website and email newsletter absolutely free. The organization makes all that money by selling print newsletters, books and events to the Daily Reckoning website visitors and email subscribers.
If "shop talk" is the next best thing to "pillow talk", the computer geeks of the world have an online paradise at TechRepublic.
The site's slogan, "Real World. Real Time. Real IT", doesn't begin to fully describe the quantity and quality of content offered here. TechRepublic provides an astounding variety of information, tools, and services created by IT professionals, for other IT professions, that help members do their jobs well.
TechRepublic is a Mequoda Hybrid Website masquerading as a membership website. Almost everything on this site is free in return for providing your email address and a little additional personal information. Access to a very few articles requires an upgraded membership in TechProGuild. After a free seven-day trial, membership in TechProGuild is $9.95 monthly (recurring billing option) or $89 annually.
TechRepublic is a property of CNET Networks, a global media company that publishes some of the best known sites on the web, targeting passionate audiences through a combination of world-class content and technology infrastructure. Its brands include Builder.com, GameSpot, mySimon, Search.com, Silicon.com, TV.com, MP3.com, BNET, ZDNet, Release 1.0 and Webshots.
TechRepublic's members, representing all segments of the IT industry, turn to TechRepublic for IT decision support and professional advice organized by job function or topic. CNET says nearly four million IT professionals depend on TechRepublic to get their jobs done. With an audience that large, TechRepublic is obviously doing something right.
Here's how it scores as measured against the 14 Mequoda Website Design Guidelines.
Just yesterday, it seems, needlecraft was the work of grandmothers. But things have changed. The craft of embroidery, for instance, has reinvented itself, in part, by calling itself ''stitching.''
Today, needlecraft includes crewel, appliqué, cross-stitch, crochet, knitting, tatting, quilting, darning and embroidery. Some of these crafts have been practiced for centuries. Samples of embroidery, for example, have been found in Egyptian tombs, on ancient Maori costumes from New Zealand and on medieval church vestments.
As a hobby, needlecraft is growing in popularity. So far in 2006, several new needlecraft magazines have been launched including Quilter's Home; Beading Basics; Cross-Stitch & Needlework and Woman's Own: Afghans.
This renaissance has created a growing demand among hobbyists for kits, supplies, tools andyou guessed itonline information, most especially, designs and patterns. New techniques enable the growing number of needlecraft hobbyists to use software for embroidery designs. Simply download the design into a sewing machine and then stitch it up!
It's a lucrative niche. According to Larry Pike, co-publisher with his wife, Holly Pike, of ArtisticThreadWorks.com, their members are 98 percent female, average age between 40 and 65, have a household income four times the national average and spend an average of $3,000 annually on their needlecraft hobby.
At ArtisticThreadWorks.com, members have access to 9,000 instantly downloadable embroidery designs for home and commercial machines. Membership is $9.95 for one month, $19.95 for three months, or $49.95 for six months.
Last month (June of 2006) saw the launch of at least 77 new magazines including such diverse titles as Jamaican Eats, Atlanta Golf, Distinctive Living and World of Sudoku. By contrast, BusinessWeek magazine has been published by McGraw-Hill since 1929.
BusinessWeek (nee The Business Week) predates Fortune magazine by only a year, and followed Forbes magazine by more than 10 years. All are American icons of the business news world, although they might be considered new kids on the block by The Economist of London, which has been in continuous publication since September of 1843.
BusinessWeek says it is the world's most widely read business magazine, with more than eight million readers each week, including online and television viewers. Its online readers at BusinessWeek.com get access to an overabundance of useful information without having to pay for a print subscription.
By almost every standard, BusinessWeek.com epitomizes the highest quality in online publishing. This website design review demonstrates how it measures up against the 14 Mequoda Website Design Guidelines.
Internet Explorer, the pundits tell us, accounts for up to 95 percent of all Web browser traffic. So why should we care about that small minority of surfers who prefer alternative browsers such as Netscape Communicator, Mozilla Firefox, Opera and Safari?
And why waste time with those non-conformist non-Windows users who are stuck with the Mac version of IE?
Answer: Because you care. Or ought to care.
For the same reason you use a spellchecker, or ought to.
Because being sloppy about details is a sign of arrogance and laziness.
Because it drastically reduces your credibility if your site appears to be amateurish or unreadable.
Most users view webpages in the 800 x 600 format. But the 640 x 480 and 1024 x 768 screen resolutions are also popular. You want your webpages to be viewable in each.
Clayton Makepeace is a legend in the direct response advertising business. He has the respect of both his clients and peersthe hallmark of a real professional.
He has a huge portfolio of winning direct mail packages, commands top dollar for his work and in April of 2006 conducted a $5,000-per-seat, how-to seminar for aspiring copywriters. I can't imagine anyone not putting his name on their top-10 list.
At MakepeaceTotalPackage.com Mr. Makepeace displays his considerable skill with one objective: to get other copywriters to sign up for his free email newsletter.
Let's see how the Copywriting and Marketing Secrets Revealed landing page measures up on the Mequoda Sales Letter Landing Page Scorecard.
In our NicheADay.com Landing Page Review we examined an information product designed for opportunity-seekers. That's a large and ever-changing market niche comprised of would-be business owners.
These are people who are dissatisfied with their jobs, or have recently become unemployed, and suddenly decide to go into business for themselves. They may suddenly embrace the "American Dream" of being self-employed and start what they hope will become a profitable business. They even call themselves entrepreneurs. One of my mentors, Michael Gerber, calls that "having an entrepreneurial seizure."
There are new entrants into the opportunity-seekers niche every week, while others abandon the dream, leave the niche and move on to alternative employment. But the desire to improve one's life, whether through self-employment or through some other self-help activity, is always a powerful force that creates a large and hungry market niche.
In his book SHAMHow the Self-Help Movement Made America Helpless,, journalist Steve Salerno offers an exposé on how "experts" dispense advice on everything from mental health to relationships to diet to personal finance to business strategy. Americans spend upward of $8 billion every year on self-help programs and products, Mr. Salerno says.
Perry Marshall is something of a Renaissance manengineer, advertising copywriter, technical writer, marketer and philosopher.
Among Internet marketers, he has ascended to the rank of high priest of Google AdWords. As one of the world's leading specialists on buying search engine traffic, he has published a very popular how-to book, conducted high-ticket seminars and is a much-sought-after personal coach.
Prior to his consulting career, he helped grow a Chicago tech company from $200,000 to $4 million in sales in four years, then sell it to a public company for $18 million.
Mr. Marshall has an engineering degree and is co-author of a book for control engineers on the essentials of Ethernet and TCP/IP. Additionally, he has worked as a stereo audio speaker designer, industrial sales manager and marketing consultant.
Mr. Marshall's book, The Definitive Guide to Google AdWords, is marketed from a sales letter landing page on his website.
Here's how it measures up on the Mequoda Sales Letter Landing Page Scorecard.
If the advent of the World Wide Web and the superabundance of information it puts within easy reach has done anything for me, it's made me a much better consumer of medical services and a greater participant in my own healthcare.
For most members of the wired world, the Internet has become our first stop for information about diseaseboth prevention and cure. Consider this: the word "cancer" was searched about 25,000 times a day at Yahoo! in March of 2006. And that's just one search engine.
With this demand for information about illness and health, it's not surprising that many physicians and traditional publishers have teamed up to begin online newsletters that address these issues. Many of these publications are highly specialized and focus on a single topic or ailment.
Others take a shotgun approach and attempt to address the public's infolust across a wide spectrum of disease prevention, physical ailments and medical remedies. The wider editorial focus that targets a greater number of potential subscribers at a relatively lower price point has a different revenue model from the smaller niche, higher price newsletter. And it creates a special problem for the newsletter marketer and copywriter.
That's because most people don't search for general health or illness prevention information. No, most people search for very ailment-specific information. If you discover that you have hypertension, for instance, you're much more likely to search high blood pressure cure than general health and wellness newsletter.
And you're more likely to respond to a sales letter that promises information about your specific ailmentin this case, high blood pressurethan to a sales letter that promises general health care advice.
That's the conundrum facing the publishers of The Blaylock Wellness Report. One sales letter landing page for that newsletter isn't nearly enough.
Now, whenever I see a URL with a number in the last part of the address, such as the one for this sitewww.newsmax.com/blaylock/20.cfmI always explore what other pages might be available if I simply change the number. You can get a great lesson in advertising copywriting this way. Have a look.
The URL www.newsmax.com/blaylock/12.cfm recommends The Blaylock Wellness Report as a cure for diabetes.
Each of these is a well-crafted sales letter landing page targeted at a different subset, or niche, of health and illness-prevention information seekers.
Let's examine just one of this collection of sales letter landing pages used by the publishers of The Blaylock Wellness Report. The URL www.newsmax.com/blaylock/13a.cfm targets users concerned about hypertension. Let's see how it measures up on the Mequoda Sales Letter Landing Page Scorecard.
Hello Guest! | Log in
Tell Me about the Library
Wine Spectator's Sips & Tips: Email Newsletter Review
InternationalLiving.com Travel Website Design Review
The Wall Street Journals Media and Marketing Edition: Email Newsletter Review
Implement a Mequoda Marketing System
MEQUODA SUMMIT
BOSTON 2008
$1197 Early-bird price ends soon!
Join Don at:
2008 American Magazine Conference
Oct 5-7, 2008
Mequoda Summit Boston 2008
Oct 14-15, 2008
Join Kim at:
2008 American Magazine Conference
Oct 5-7, 2008
Mequoda Summit Boston 2008
Oct 14-15, 2008
Join Amanda at:
SocialMediaCamp Boston
Aug 5, 2008
Mequoda Summit Boston 2008
Oct 14-15, 2008